POSITIVE ENT · DIZZINESS AND BALANCE · PART 5
Prof. Dr. Erol Egeli
So far in this series I have set out the terms, how a wrong name takes hold, and how I remove it. Here is what all of it looks like in one person. Identifying details have been generalised or left out so that the patient and her family cannot be recognised; the course of the story is unchanged.
A woman in her early forties came into my room held up on either side by her husband and her husband’s sister.
She was not moving her head at all. She looked straight ahead and held herself rigid, as though bending or turning had been forbidden, and she could only walk with support. There was a cervical collar around her neck. It took both of them, very slowly, to get her into the chair.
It was an alarming sight. She looked like someone with serious neurological disease. The two people with her were close to panic.
I assumed it was serious
The first thing I did at that point was not to reassure anyone. The opposite.
Faced with a presentation like that, a clinician’s first question is whether this is an emergency. An event involving the brainstem or the cerebellum can produce exactly this picture. So can an acute vestibular syndrome. In some of them, hours count.
So I began to watch carefully. How she sat. Why she never turned her head. How her eyes moved. What happened while she spoke. Slowly, it became clear that the picture was not as grave as it looked. But I did not assume that at the outset; I excluded it by examination.
I stress this because it is the point in this article most open to being misunderstood. Nothing I describe below can be done before serious disease has been ruled out.
The pile on the desk
The patient and her husband began to talk. She had been in a wretched state for two months. The dizziness was severe. She had given up her job. At home she could do nothing either, and spent most of the day lying still.
They had been to hospital repeatedly. Nothing had improved. The tests and the medications were stacked up in front of me. At one hospital she had been given a collar to keep her neck immobile.
I carried out a detailed ear, nose and throat examination and a neurological examination. There was not a single positive finding.
What had happened three months earlier
As I took the history further, she said her sleep had become markedly worse recently.
Then the thing that mattered came out. Three months earlier, a close member of the family had been diagnosed with a serious illness. She had been badly shaken by it. She was lying awake into the early hours.
And somewhere in there the direction of the fear had changed. It was no longer about the person she loved. It had turned back on her own body.
The spiral
What followed was the cycle described earlier in this series, running like a textbook example.
Every new test brought that question back to life. And what wore her down was less the test itself than the wait for the appointment. Each period of waiting meant the question running in her mind one more time. When a result came back normal, the relief was brief, because the next appointment was already approaching.
The collar was a layer of its own. Her neck had been immobilised. On top of that she had been advised not to move while sleeping. So the sleep that was already disturbed became worse, and her movement was restricted completely.
The balance system recovers through movement, and consolidates that recovery in sleep. Two pieces of well-meant advice had switched off both of them at once.
There was one more layer, and perhaps the least noticed. The people around her saw the state she was in and panicked; they took her arm, helped her to sit, supported her when she walked. They did this out of love. But every day, every hour, the patient was receiving the same message from her surroundings: you really are very ill.
The consultation
As the history went on, something interesting happened: she had already begun to focus on the source herself. While the questions continued, she was assembling her own chronology.
I explained what true vertigo is. What an illusion of movement is, how it comes on, how long it lasts. Then I asked: is that what yours is like?
Her answer was clear. No.
We talked it through: she did not have vertigo; what she had been through had disturbed her state of mind and her sleep; her symptoms were coming from there. I did not explain it to her — we built it together. She was already saying most of it herself.
Then I stopped and asked: has it all settled in your mind?
She answered immediately. Yes.
Do you know now what this is? I asked.
The lift
Everything up to this point had been verbal. I explained, she asked, she understood, she confirmed. But there is a distance between understanding something and believing it, and words do not close that distance.
I said to her: you came in here on two people’s arms. In fact you can walk by yourself, without being afraid.
Yes, she said.
Then can you walk to the lift on your own now?
And she stood up. With nobody holding her arm, in front of all of us, she walked to the lift door.
Everything we had said until that moment was a claim. That walk was the evidence — and the evidence was produced by her, not by me. A doctor saying “you can walk” is an opinion. The patient walking is data.
That short distance had one more audience: her husband and her sister-in-law. The two people who had been holding her up for two months watched her walk alone. The behaviour that had been confirming the patient’s role every day ended there, on its own.
What happened afterwards
At her follow-up she reported that the light-headedness had gone within a few days.
They came once more after that — this time for her husband, with something else entirely.
What this case shows
Over twelve weeks, no one did this patient any harm. Everyone acted in good faith: the doctor who ordered the tests, the doctor who gave her the collar, the husband who took her arm.
But here is what it added up to. A fear that had never been named was fed by a spiral of testing; movement was restricted; sleep was disrupted; and the affection of the people around her confirmed her role as a patient, daily. Not one of these was a mistake on its own. Their sum produced an illness.
The cost of that illness was not only what she felt. In twelve weeks she gave up her job, made repeated hospital visits and underwent a series of tests, and two other adults reorganised their days around her. A name given wrongly is expensive — for the patient, for the people around her, and for a health system that goes on investigating a question it has already answered.
What resolved it was not a new test or a new medication. A properly conducted examination; then a consultation that allowed the patient to construct her own story; and finally a walk of a few steps that let her test it against her own body.
That is the summary of what I have been saying since the beginning of this series. In dizziness, getting the name right is not a step that comes before treatment. Most of the time it is the treatment.
| What this article does not say This case does not mean that dizziness is psychological, or that testing is unnecessary. Another patient presenting in exactly the same way might have had a serious event involving the cerebellum; that is precisely why the first thing I did was to assume it was serious. The approach described here comes into play after a detailed history, an ear, nose and throat examination and a neurological examination have been completed and serious causes excluded. Nor does any consultation close the door: if the character of the symptoms changes, or new findings appear, the assessment is carried out again from the beginning. |
NEXT IN THE SERIES
Part 6 — Another case from my practice.
Positive ENT · Dizziness and Balance · Part 5 | Prof. Dr. Erol Egeli | positiveent.com
This article is intended for general education and does not replace individual medical assessment. Identifying details of this case — including age, family circumstances and the nature of the relative’s illness — have been generalised or omitted, and no detail permitting recognition of the patient or her family has been retained. Only the clinical course is reported as it occurred. Dizziness has many causes, some of which require prompt attention.
Sources
Bisdorff A, von Brevern M, Lempert T, Newman-Toker DE. Classification of vestibular symptoms: towards an international classification of vestibular disorders. Journal of Vestibular Research, 2009;19(1–2):1–13.
Staab JP, Eckhardt-Henn A, Horii A, et al. Diagnostic criteria for persistent postural-perceptual dizziness (PPPD). Journal of Vestibular Research, 2017;27(4):191–208.
Bárány Society Classification Oversight Committee. The Bárány Society position on ‘cervical dizziness’. Journal of Vestibular Research, 2022;32(6):487–499.
Hall CD, Herdman SJ, Whitney SL, et al. Vestibular rehabilitation for peripheral vestibular hypofunction: an updated clinical practice guideline from the Academy of Neurologic Physical Therapy of the American Physical Therapy Association. Journal of Neurologic Physical Therapy, 2022;46(2):118–177.
