POSITIVE ENT · DIZZINESS AND BALANCE · PART 6
Prof. Dr. Erol Egeli
Four months, an MRI, an EEG, an ECG, an echocardiogram and a battery of balance tests. All of them normal. The answer was waiting in a question none of those machines could ask: what exactly do you mean when you say you faint?
As in the previous article, the identifying details of this case have been kept deliberately indeterminate.
A schoolgirl in her early teens came in with her mother and father. The complaint had been going on for four months and was expressed in a single word: fainting.
It happened at school. Sometimes on the bus.
The family were in a state of panic — and by now that panic was a problem in its own right. The girl’s work for the national examination for high school places had fallen off. But it had not stopped there: her mother and father were also performing worse at work, and the days they could not go in were adding up. The whole household had locked itself onto this one matter.
At the hospitals they had already been to, she had undergone magnetic resonance imaging, an EEG, an ECG, an echocardiogram and vestibular testing. Nothing had been found in any of them. The symptoms had continued without easing at all.
Examination and exclusion
I took a detailed history and carried out an ear, nose and throat examination and a neurological examination. There was no finding suggesting pathology.
Fainting in an adolescent is not something to be taken lightly, so I worked through the things that have to be ruled out, one by one. Was there a history of palpitations? Did it happen during exertion? Was there a family history of sudden death at a young age? I asked about her eating and her fluid intake — and about breakfast in particular, since the episodes at school and on the bus pointed that way. There was nothing in any of it, and the cardiac and neurological assessments had already come back normal.
One question was left. And it was the question nobody had asked in four months.
“Fainting”
I asked her to describe, in detail, exactly what she experienced in those moments.
As she talked, the picture changed.
She had never fallen. She had never lost consciousness. What she was describing was the feeling of being about to faint. On one occasion in class, she said, it had felt “as if I collapsed onto the desk” — but even then she had not slid from her chair.
So this was not syncope. It was presyncope.
What had set off four months of investigation was not a finding. It was a word.
I want to underline this, because nobody had done anything wrong. The girl was not making it up; she really was experiencing something. Her family had behaved correctly: if your child is fainting, you take her to a doctor. The doctors had behaved correctly too; when “fainting” is what you hear, you investigate the heart and the brain.
But right at the start of the chain there was a point at which everyone was using the same word and meaning different things by it. In the first article of this series I wrote that the feeling of being about to faint belongs in a category of its own and should not be confused with dizziness. Here we are looking at the same confusion running the other way: presyncope had been taken for syncope.
The ground beneath it
Once the name of the complaint had shifted, the real question remained: why was she feeling this at all?
Two things came out.
The first was that the pressure of the examination had started. She was not performing at the level she expected of herself, and she knew it.
The second, and the more concrete: her sleep had fallen apart. What is interesting is that neither she nor her family had noticed. It had not even occurred to them as a problem.
There was a television in her bedroom. There was a computer. The mobile phone came all the way into the bed with her. The late-night social media loop we all recognise had taken hold.
In four months, not one investigation had looked at that room.
The consultation
I explained why sleep matters this much: that the brain can only prepare for the next day through sleep that is sufficient and regular, and what the body does when that setting is disturbed. Poor sleep quality is associated with more dizziness in the general population, and the association is stronger in people who do not have a vestibular disorder — which is where she was.
Then I said the concrete thing: the television, the computer and the mobile phone should not be in the bedroom. I explained that they were wrecking her sleep.
She was smiling as she listened. She seemed to be accepting it — as though what I was saying was not new to her.
I asked: have you understood the relationship between your sleep and what you have been feeling?
Then came the part that mattered. I did not have to repeat that the devices should leave the bedroom — she said it herself. She and her mother said they would make that change in the room straight away.
This is another instance of what I described in the earlier article: patients are usually not learning something they did not know. Something they did know is being named, and they are being allowed to change it.
What happened next
Her mother telephoned me three days later.
She thanked me, and made an appointment for her other child, about something else entirely.
What this case shows
Not one of the tests was unnecessary. When “fainting” is what you hear, those tests are ordered; not ordering them would have been a failure.
The problem was not in the tests but in the question they were answering. All of them were looking for an answer to why is this child fainting? The question that needed asking was: is this child fainting at all?
That question cannot be asked by a machine. It can only be asked in a consultation with enough time set aside for it, by letting the child describe things in her own words.
The second thing this case shows is that for four months the patient was not only the child. Her mother’s and father’s working lives had been disrupted; the whole household had locked itself onto the matter. Uncertainty does not stay in one person; it spreads to everyone around them. Which is why getting the name right often settles not one person but a family.
One word about the two cases in this series. I chose them because they show the mechanism clearly, not because every patient’s course is this quick.
| What must not be overlooked in fainting This case does not mean that fainting in adolescents can be treated lightly — it shows the opposite, since this child had already had a cardiac and neurological assessment and both were normal. Medical advice, including cardiac assessment, should always be sought in the following situations: fainting during exertion or sport; palpitations beforehand; sudden fainting with no warning symptoms at all; injury sustained during the episode; a family history of unexplained sudden death at a young age. Episodes with genuine loss of consciousness, with accompanying convulsive movements, or followed by prolonged confusion also require separate assessment. International guidance takes the same view from the other direction: in a young person with no cardiac history, no family history of sudden death, no fainting while lying down or during exercise, and a normal ECG, the likelihood of a cardiac cause is very low. |
And finally, the point I have made from the beginning of this series comes round once more. Getting the name of a complaint right is not the first step on the road to treatment. Most of the time it is the treatment.
ABOUT THIS SERIES
This article closes the case histories in this series: what vertigo is, how a wrong name takes hold, how that name is removed, who is more susceptible to the picture, and how all of it looks in two patients. For anyone reading from the beginning, the first part is the place to start.
NEXT IN THIS SERIES
Part 7 — Everyone in the house: the people who arrive alongside the patient with no complaint of their own, and what happens to a household when one person’s sleep is put right.
Positive ENT · Dizziness and Balance · Part 6 | Prof. Dr. Erol Egeli | positiveent.com
This article is intended for general education and does not replace individual medical assessment. Identifying details of this case — including age, school, family circumstances and the timing of events — have been generalised or omitted, and no detail permitting recognition of the patient or her family has been retained. Only the clinical course is reported as it occurred. Fainting and dizziness have many causes, some of which require prompt attention.
Sources
Bisdorff A, von Brevern M, Lempert T, Newman-Toker DE. Classification of vestibular symptoms: towards an international classification of vestibular disorders. Journal of Vestibular Research, 2009;19(1–2):1–13.
Brignole M, Moya A, de Lange FJ, et al. 2018 ESC Guidelines for the diagnosis and management of syncope. European Heart Journal, 2018;39(21):1883–1948.
Hoepel SJW, Jouvencel A, van Linge A, Goedegebure A, Altena E, Luik AI. Sleep and dizziness in middle-aged and elderly persons: a cross-sectional population-based study. Sleep Epidemiology, 2023;3:100066.
