POSITIVE ENT · DIZZINESS AND BALANCE · PART 4
Prof. Dr. Erol Egeli
Two people go through the same disrupted week. One feels nothing. The other is light-headed for days. Over the years I have been struck by how much the people in that second group resemble one another: their sleep, their blood pressure, and something that goes back to childhood.
In the previous article I described how, while removing a wrong label, I question the way a patient lives. Having conducted that same enquiry in the same way for years, I began to notice something recurring.
Patients who describe light-headedness are not distributed at random. People carrying certain characteristics react to the same irregularity markedly faster and markedly more severely. Below I set out three of them. They are my clinical observations; for each one I also give what the literature says as it stands, strengths and weaknesses alike.
ONE
Sleep
I put this first because it is more decisive than the other two.
Being able to cope with the day, physically and mentally, depends on adequate sleep and rest. This is not a preference about feeling well; it is a requirement of a nervous system that has to reset itself for the following day. The balance system is part of that reset.
Most of my patients do not know their sleep is disturbed. The reason they do not know is interesting: they think of sleep only as duration. They say “I sleep seven hours” and count it as sufficient. But other things determine its quality.
Regular hours. Going to bed and getting up at the same time each day is more decisive than total duration. Weekends included.
Adequate length. For most adults, seven to nine hours a night.
Darkness and quiet. Light is the most powerful regulator of the body clock that governs the sleep cycle.
Screens before bed. They delay sleep onset through light and through mental arousal alike.
The timing of caffeine and alcohol. Alcohol makes falling asleep easier and then disrupts the second half of the night.
Continuity. Sleep that adds up to enough but arrives in fragments does not substitute for the same number of unbroken hours.
When I go through these with a patient, most of them see for themselves that their sleep is not as good as they had assumed. And that makes the next step easier: what has to change is no longer an abstract “way of living” but a handful of countable habits.
The evidence behind this observation is solid. In the population-based Rotterdam Study, the relationship between sleep and dizziness was examined in 4,702 people; poorer self-reported sleep quality was associated with more dizziness. The detail that matters most for us is this: the association was stronger for non-vestibular dizziness — which is to say, in precisely the group of patients this series is about. The same study notes that dizziness affects roughly a third of the population by the age of seventy.
But the reach of sleep does not end there, and this is the part most patients have never heard. Disturbed sleep does not only produce light-headedness. It is also a trigger for genuine inner ear disease. Sleep deprivation is a recognised provoking factor in Ménière’s disease, in vestibular migraine and in persistent postural-perceptual dizziness.
Benign paroxysmal positional vertigo is a less settled question, and I will set it out as it stands. Sleep disturbance appears among the factors examined in relation to recurrence, but the studies have been small and the conclusions remain uncertain. What is better established is narrower and more practical: among patients treated with a repositioning manoeuvre, those who slept on the affected side in the following week had a higher rate of recurrence than those who slept in other positions.
So sleep is everyone’s business, whatever the diagnosis. In one group it is the source of the complaint; in another, the trigger for its return.
TWO
People whose blood pressure runs low
My second observation is this. People whose blood pressure runs persistently low — a systolic reading of 110 or below where 120 would be usual, often 100, sometimes 90 — are far more quickly affected by an irregular life, and what they feel is light-headedness.
For that reason I measure these patients’ blood pressure during the examination and ask about earlier readings. The answer usually points the same way: not high blood pressure but a tendency to low.
I see these patients’ weeks unravel after a night or two of broken sleep. The most accurate way to put it may be that their margin for recovery is narrow.
Here I have to be honest, because the subject is contested in the literature.
In continental European medicine, chronic low blood pressure remains a working concept, used to account for a range of constitutional complaints. In English-speaking countries the prevailing view for decades has been that low blood pressure does not by itself produce symptoms.
There is supporting data. In the Whitehall II study of 10,314 British civil servants, low systolic blood pressure was associated with unexplained tiredness in both sexes, and with dizziness and light-headedness in men.
But the same study contains a second finding that matters just as much. Once the level of psychological distress was taken into account, the association between blood pressure and these complaints was no longer significant. Whether low blood pressure directly produces the symptoms, or simply keeps company with them in the same people, is unresolved.
I include that finding because taking the part of a study that supports my observation and passing over the part that does not would be wrong. My own reading is this: what we are probably dealing with is not a single haemodynamic mechanism but a pattern that involves the whole person. The person whose blood pressure runs low may also be the person who feels a load sooner. In clinic I see the two together, and the intervention addresses both at once.
THREE
People who were travel-sick as children
My third observation is the least expected. When I ask these patients about their childhood, a substantial proportion say they were easily made sick by cars, buses, ferries or aeroplanes. In some of them it continues into adult life.
I now ask this routinely, because it is not something a patient will volunteer. Nobody arrives complaining of dizziness and opens with “cars always made me sick when I was a child.”
The literature behind this observation is strong — but what it points to is more specific than one might expect.
Motion sensitivity is markedly more common in people with migraine; something in the order of two thirds report it. That association has been examined directly in a large American study of a student population, which found motion sickness susceptibility and vestibular migraine closely linked. A childhood history of travel sickness is particularly common in vestibular migraine, significantly more so than in persistent postural-perceptual dizziness.
A practical screening question has been validated for exactly this purpose. In a study of ninety-two patients with definite vestibular migraine, fifty-eight with migraine alone and seventy-four controls, a single question — can you read while travelling in a car without getting motion sick? — detected motion sickness susceptibility about as reliably as a full questionnaire. Being unable to read while travelling turned out to be a useful pointer towards vestibular migraine.
The conclusion that follows is this. In some proportion of dizzy patients with a childhood history of travel sickness, what is actually present may be an undiagnosed vestibular migraine. In these patients it is therefore worth asking separately about headache history, about sensitivity to light and sound, and about migraine in the family.
None of this displaces the approach built around how a person lives — the best-recognised triggers of vestibular migraine are, after all, sleeplessness, irregularity and stress. But in this group, treatment directed at the migraine may be needed in addition to a change of routine.
The common denominator: living by the clock
People carrying these three characteristics share one recurring outcome: their tolerance for irregularity is low.
Two people go through the same disrupted week. One may feel nothing at all. The other, the one carrying these three characteristics, is light-headed for days. This is not a weakness; it is a narrow margin of adjustment in the nervous system.
So what I tell these patients is this: you need to live by the clock. Bed at the same hour, up at the same hour, meals and fluids not skipped. What is flexibility for other people is, for you, a cost.
I present this not as a restriction but as an advantage — because that is what it is. Being sensitive to irregularity also means benefiting quickly from regularity. In these patients, a few weeks of consistent sleep usually makes a more visible difference than any medication.
| What this article does not say What is listed here is a set of observations about susceptibility, not a diagnostic checklist. Carrying these characteristics does not mean that the cause of a person’s dizziness must be the way they live; not carrying them does not mean that it plays no part. Every case of dizziness should first be assessed with a detailed history, an ear, nose and throat examination and a neurological examination. In addition, low blood pressure that is new, that is accompanied by fainting, or that began with a medication, is a situation requiring investigation in its own right. |
Across four articles I have now set out the terms, how a wrong name takes hold, how I remove it, and who is more susceptible to this picture. What remains is how all of it looks in actual people.
NEXT IN THIS SERIES
Part 5 — Cases from my practice: patients who arrive with the same sentence and turn out to have entirely different problems.
Positive ENT · Dizziness and Balance · Part 4 | Prof. Dr. Erol Egeli | positiveent.com
This article is intended for general education and does not replace individual medical assessment. Dizziness has many causes, some of which require prompt attention.
Sources
Hoepel SJW, Jouvencel A, van Linge A, Goedegebure A, Altena E, Luik AI. Sleep and dizziness in middle-aged and elderly persons: a cross-sectional population-based study. Sleep Epidemiology, 2023;3:100066.
Pilgrim JA, Stansfeld S, Marmot M. Low blood pressure, low mood? BMJ, 1992;304(6819):75–78.
Abouzari M, Cheung D, Pham T, et al. The relationship between vestibular migraine and motion sickness susceptibility. Otology & Neurotology, 2020;41(8):1116–1121.
Akdal G, Özçelik P, Balçı B, Halmágyi GM, Ünal B. One simple question detects motion sickness susceptibility in migraine patients. Brazilian Journal of Otorhinolaryngology, 2024;90(2):101382.
Li S, Tian L, Han Z, Wang J. Impact of postmaneuver sleep position on recurrence of benign paroxysmal positional vertigo. PLoS ONE, 2013;8(12):e83566.
Staab JP, Eckhardt-Henn A, Horii A, et al. Diagnostic criteria for persistent postural-perceptual dizziness (PPPD). Journal of Vestibular Research, 2017;27(4):191–208.
Lempert T, Olesen J, Furman J, et al. Vestibular migraine: diagnostic criteria. Journal of Vestibular Research, 2012;22(4):167–172.
Bisdorff A, von Brevern M, Lempert T, Newman-Toker DE. Classification of vestibular symptoms: towards an international classification of vestibular disorders. Journal of Vestibular Research, 2009;19(1–2):1–13.
