POSITIVE ENT · DIZZINESS AND BALANCE PART 3
Prof. Dr. Erol Egeli
You do not remove a wrong diagnosis by telling the patient they do not have it, and you do not remove it by offering a better name. The only thing that works is letting the patient find the connection in their own history.
BIn the previous article I described how a wrong name settles onto a patient with dizziness, and why it is then carried for years. Now the harder question: how do you take a ten-year-old label off?
Two answers suggest themselves immediately, and both fail.
Telling the patient they do not have vertigo does not work. The sentence delivers information but leaves a vacuum. The patient has lived with an explanation for a decade; take it away and put nothing in its place, and they will go looking for a replacement. Usually they find it at the next clinic. The evidence on reassurance points in the same direction: across fourteen randomised trials involving nearly 3,800 patients, testing carried out specifically to reassure people at low risk of serious disease produced no meaningful reduction in anxiety, in worry about illness, or in symptoms. Those trials were about tests rather than sentences, but the mechanism is the same one — reassurance built on what is absent rarely lasts.
Substituting a new name does not work either. Saying “this is not vertigo, it is anxiety-related dizziness” is easy and may even be technically correct. But the patient goes home and researches that phrase instead, and the cycle restarts. The stone has not come out of the well. It has landed in a different one.
The consultation described below settled into its present shape over years of running into those two dead ends. It does not finish in thirty minutes; these patients routinely take more than an hour. I set that down not as a method to be admired but as an honest account of how long the work actually takes.
FIRST STEP
Examination before conversation
Before anything else I take a detailed history. Then an ear, nose and throat examination and a neurological examination. Where indicated, audiometry and vestibular assessment are added.
This order is not open to discussion. Nothing described below can take place before genuine disease has been excluded. Dizziness has serious causes, and some of them do not tolerate delay. Listening to a patient is not a substitute for examining one; the two are done together.
This step has a second function that is seldom mentioned. Being listened to at length, and being properly examined, builds trust. Everything that follows is built on it.
SECOND STEP
Explaining the mechanism
I explain how the balance system works: what the balance organ in the inner ear does, how the brain combines information arriving from the eyes, the muscles and the inner ear, and what happens when one of those inputs is disturbed.
This is not preamble. It is the ground the patient needs in order to make their own judgement at the next step. Before someone can assess what is happening to them, they have to know how the system is supposed to behave.
THIRD STEP
Handing the criterion to the patient
Then I describe the criterion itself. What true vertigo is and is not. What an illusion of movement feels like, how long it lasts, what sets it off, how it resolves.
And I ask: does this happen to you?
The patient answers. Almost always the answer is no.
The difference here looks small and is in fact everything. I am not telling the patient they do not have vertigo. I am giving them the criterion, they are applying it to themselves, and they are seeing the result for themselves. A conclusion a person has reached on their own is not given up as easily as one they were handed.
FOURTH STEP
Getting to the actual cause
Once the name has shifted, the real question remains: why is this light-headedness happening at all?
Here I ask about how the person lives. Sleep — the hours it keeps, its quality, not merely its length. The load carried at work and at home. Anxieties held for a long time, losses, difficult periods. I ask these things by letting the patient tell their own story, not by working through a questionnaire.
Then I ask them to build the chronology. When did these symptoms start? When did they get worse? What was happening in your life during those periods?
And here, almost every time, the patient makes the connection. Not me. They put the onset of their symptoms next to the point their life lost its order, and the flare-ups next to the periods of strain. Often they do it before I have finished asking.
The reason is that none of this information is new to them. At some level they already knew. Nobody had asked.
Patients make this connection with striking ease, and their education has little to do with it. They are not learning something they did not know. They are being given permission to say something they did.
After years of running the same enquiry the same way, I began to notice a pattern: some people are markedly more prone to this picture than others. Their sleep, their blood pressure and something carried over from childhood turn out to be held in common. That is the subject of the next article.
FIFTH STEP
Checking that it has landed
Then I stop and ask: do you understand where your problem comes from? Has it settled in your mind?
Asking is important, because you cannot proceed without hearing the answer. Assuming that what was explained has taken hold on the other side is one of the most frequent errors in clinical practice. A patient may be nodding. Nodding is not understanding.
At this point my patients’ answers are usually very clear. When I hear that clarity, I know the consultation has done its real work.
SIXTH STEP
Ending without a prescription
Then I say this: for years you have carried something that was not true, and you have made it bigger in the carrying. We are correcting it now. And in correcting it I am not going to prescribe anything — because you are the one who has understood the relationship, and you are the one who will put it right.
That sentence does two separate jobs.
The first is that it states the reason for not prescribing. A patient who leaves without a prescription and without an explanation concludes that there was nothing wrong with them and that they were not taken seriously. Give the reason and the same situation becomes something else entirely.
The second, and the more important, is that it puts responsibility where it belongs. Someone who has held the role of a patient for ten years is being invited to set that role down. Sleep, daily rhythm, the burdens being carried — these are things that can be worked on. And the person who will do the work is the patient.
There is a second reason, and it has nothing to do with this patient’s psychology. The reflex prescription in dizziness is a vestibular suppressant, and the cost of that reflex has been measured. In a United States claims analysis of 190,348 adults aged sixty-five and over presenting with dizziness, roughly a third filled a prescription for a vestibular suppressant within a month. Among those who did, eight percent had a fall requiring medical attention within the following two months, and after adjustment the prescription was associated with more than a threefold increase in the risk of falling. Current guidance already recommends against the routine use of these drugs. They have a place in the first days of an acute vestibular crisis; beyond that they blunt the very signal the brain needs in order to recalibrate, which is to say they work against the recovery they were given for.
This does not mean that no one is ever prescribed anything. If migraine is present, migraine is treated. If there is an underlying problem, that problem is addressed. Where there is vestibular hypofunction, the patient is referred for vestibular rehabilitation, for which the evidence is strong and the exercises are specific. If psychiatric support is needed, that is discussed openly. What is described here applies to one group of patients only: the patient whose assessment is complete, in whom no structural cause has been found, and who has spent years under a wrong label.
SEVENTH STEP
Sharing the burden
The last part of the consultation is the most unusual. Here I tell the patient about my own position.
I say: for ten years you have wondered whether there is something wrong with you, and you have gone looking. As of today, a serious illness could appear in you or in me, by coincidence. If it appears in me, it will be new. If it appears in you, you will interpret it through the relationship you built ten years ago. That is the hardest part of my work.
Let me explain why I say it.
The asymmetry described in the previous article is real: applying a label carries no risk, removing one does. I am taking that risk. But I am not hiding it from the person it concerns.
The result surprises me every time. The patient is not frightened. On the contrary — having seen what has been done for them over the preceding hour, they can see the position the person opposite them is in. From that moment the relationship stops being one-way care. There is an uncertainty both sides know about, and nothing is being withheld.
One of the things clinical practice has taught me: shared information does not frighten patients. What frightens them is the space left by information that was not shared.
| What this article does not say None of this means that dizziness is usually psychological, or that there is no need to see a doctor. The entire consultation described here begins after a detailed history, an ear, nose and throat examination and a neurological examination, and after genuine disease has been excluded. Nor does any consultation close the door: if the character of the symptoms changes, if new ones appear, or if any of the warning signs listed in Part 1 emerge, the assessment starts again from the beginning. |
Why I call this a craft
Not one of the steps above is unusual in itself. All of them are part of a medical education. What is unusual is doing all of them in a single consultation, in the right order, with enough time.
As experience accumulates, the steps stop being a checklist you work through. You begin to know where to place the weight with a particular patient, which silence not to interrupt, when to ask a question and when to wait. At that point the work stops being a method you apply and becomes something you practise. Experience turns into craft, and craft gives a clinician confidence.
Without that confidence, the seventh step is not possible either. To speak openly with a patient about your own uncertainty, you first have to trust your own assessment.
It is also here that the question of what Positive ENT actually is gets its answer. It is not saying things to patients that make them feel better. It is saying the accurate thing in a form the patient can assemble for themselves. The difference becomes visible in what the patient is holding at the end of the consultation: a new label, or an understood connection in their own life.
NEXT IN THIS SERIES
Part 4 — Who is more susceptible: sleep, blood pressure, and motion sensitivity carried over from childhood.
Positive ENT · Dizziness and Balance · Part 3 | Prof. Dr. Erol Egeli | positiveent.com
This article is intended for general education and does not replace individual medical assessment. Dizziness has many causes, some of which require prompt attention.
Sources
Bisdorff A, von Brevern M, Lempert T, Newman-Toker DE. Classification of vestibular symptoms: towards an international classification of vestibular disorders. Journal of Vestibular Research, 2009;19(1–2):1–13.
Rolfe A, Burton C. Reassurance after diagnostic testing with a low pretest probability of serious disease: systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Internal Medicine, 2013;173(6):407–416.
Hall CD, Herdman SJ, Whitney SL, et al. Vestibular rehabilitation for peripheral vestibular hypofunction: an updated clinical practice guideline from the Academy of Neurologic Physical Therapy of the American Physical Therapy Association. Journal of Neurologic Physical Therapy, 2022;46(2):118–177.
Lempert T, Olesen J, Furman J, et al. Vestibular migraine: diagnostic criteria. Journal of Vestibular Research, 2012;22(4):167–172.
Marmor S, Karaca-Mandic P, Adams ME. Vestibular suppressant utilization and subsequent falls among patients 65 years and older with dizziness in the United States. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2025;73(5):1398–1405.
Bhattacharyya N, Gubbels SP, Schwartz SR, et al. Clinical practice guideline: benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (update). Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, 2017;156(3_suppl):S1–S47.
